Lindsey's review of my book: Sex As God Intended

One of John McNeill’s most significant contributions to Christian theology in Sex As God Intended (which builds on his previous works, including his classic study The Church and the Homosexual [1976]) is his carefully worked-out insistence that gay and lesbian human beings fit into God’s plan for the world. McNeill not merely asserts this: he demonstrates why it is the case, and he does so using unimpeachably traditional building blocks of Christian theology to make his case.

McNeill situates the lives of gay persons—he situates our existence in the world, an existence willed by the Creator—within the longstanding Christian tradition that through Christ, God has caught the entire cosmos up into a grand drama of divine salvation, in which all that has been created has a role to play in moving the created world to liberation. Echoing the Pauline insistence that the whole universe groans for salvation, and the declaration of patristic thinkers such as Irenaeus that the Spirit moves within all creation to make it (including human beings) fully alive, John McNeill asks what particular gifts gay and lesbian persons bring to the human community, to assist it in its movement to full life.

To ask this is also to ask precisely what it is that makes the human community fully alive. To ask about the particular gifts that gay and lesbian persons offer the human community is to ask about the eschatological goal towards which we move, as a human community. What is it to be liberated, to be saved? What does this mean, concretely? From what exactly do we seek salvation?

John McNeill’s thought is incisive on this point. In his view, the Western mind (and the mind of the human community in general) has, throughout history, been involved in a constant dialectic interplay between the masculine and the feminine (Sex As God Intended, p. 100). McNeill notes that great religious founders including Jesus and Ignatius of Loyola were, in cultures and historic periods heavily dominated by a masculine mind, “extraordinarily open to the feminine” (ibid.). He attributes the fruitfulness of such religious founders’ vision to their ability to draw on the creative energies of the feminine in cultures and periods resistant to the feminine.

In McNeill’s view, the human community is currently undergoing deep crisis as it attempts to move beyond the crippling strictures of a masculine mindset imbued with heterosexism and driven by feminophobia (pp. 98, 114). McNeill sees inbuilt in modernity itself “an essentially masculine crisis” (p. 105). The modern period joined the fate of the human race—and of the world itself—to men’s domination of women, to the subjugation of the feminine to the masculine, to the denigration of gay and lesbian human beings by heterosexual ones. In doing so, it has brought the human community (and the world itself) to a perilous point, at which we face the annihilation of everything by nuclear war and unbridled ecological destruction (p. 105).

The salvation of the world depends, then, on the ability of the human race to move beyond the intransigent, stubborn defense of masculine domination of everything, in our current postmodern moment. Unfortunately, at this point of peril, some churches, including the Roman Catholic church, have chosen to make the defense of masculine domination of everything so central to their definition of what it means to be a believer in the world today, that many churches view the attempt to correct the exclusively masculine worldview we have inherited as apocalyptic: to question the right of males to dominate is to court the destruction of the world (p. 110). Churches are impeding a necessary movement forward by the human community, by clinging to outmoded, unjust patriarchal ideas and structures, at a point in which those ideas and structures are revealed as increasingly toxic wherever they prevail.



Sts. Sergius and Bacchus


What do gays and lesbians, who are increasingly the human fallout of the churches’ adamantine resistance to the feminine, have to offer in this dialectical struggle for the future of the world? In McNeill’s view, gays and lesbians have a providential opportunity to “model the ideal goal of humanity’s present evolution,” by demonstrating what it might mean to live with a balance of masculine and feminine principles inside oneself and in the culture at large (p. 115). Gays and lesbians can offer, simply by living our lives with unapologetic integrity, an example of “balanced synthesis” that a culture heavily dominated by fear of the feminine and unjust power of the masculine sorely needs, if it is to remain a viable culture.

John McNeill follows his sketch of the dialectic evolutionary process through which humanity is now moving—or, rather, has to move, if it hopes to overcome forces with the perilous ability to destroy the entire world—with a reminder of the special gifts that gay and lesbian persons bring to church and society. This Jungian-oriented analysis of the contributions of gays and lesbians to humanity is one that runs through everything McNeill has written. It sustains his thought, and is one of his most valuable contributions to Christian theology.

Following Jung, McNeill notes that gays and lesbians bring these gifts to the human community and the churches:

Deep bonds of love, which bear an often unacknowledged fruit in many social institutions that transcend the gay community itself;
A sensitivity to beauty;
Supreme gifts of compassionate service evident in the contributions of gay and lesbian teachers, ministers, medical workers and healers, workers in the fields of human service that serve the blind, those with mental and physical challenges, and so on, and many other service-oriented fields;
An interest in and commitment to preserving the best of traditions, aspects of tradition that remain viable and are often overlooked by mainstream culture;
And the gift of spiritual leadership.
One cannot read John McNeill’s work without concluding that the church’s decision at this moment of its history to reject—even to seek to destroy—such gifts is tragically short-sighted. One cannot read John McNeill’s work while struggling, as an unapologetic gay person, to live in some connection to the church without feeling the tremendous weight of the tragedy that the churches are choosing to write today for themselves, the human community, and the earth itself by repudiating and undermining the gifts of gay and lesbian persons to the churches and the human community.

The unfinished question with which John McNeill’s theology leaves me, as a gay believer, is the question of what to do about that tragedy. For anyone who is unabashedly gay and who continues to believe that it is important to connect to the churches—for anyone who sees her or his sexual orientation as a gift of the same God whom the churches worship—the tragedy the churches are manufacturing by their cruel rejection of gay and lesbian believers produces existential, vocational crisis today.

How to live with any connection to an institution capable of such anti-Christian malevolence, an institution that not only has the capability to twist the souls of gay human beings, but which all too often gleefully uses that capability to do precisely that—to assault the very personhood of gay human beings in the name of a God who is Love? How to live with any connection to an institution that practices and foments violence against oneself and others like oneself, while preaching a commitment to peace and love? What to do about an institution that transmits rich spiritual resources of which one wishes to avail oneself, but which also introduces a stream of toxins into one’s life and into society, through its malevolence towards queer human beings? How to forgive an institution which tells one that it is the way to salvation, and at the same time closes that way to any gay person who refuses to curse God for the gift of his or her nature?

I don’t know the answer to these questions—not fully. I continue struggling to pursue answer to these soul-searching questions in my own life, and in my life as it is lived in solidarity with others who share this struggle. As a Catholic layperson, I sense that I sometimes have to look for answers in a different place than the place in which John McNeill (and James Alison, whose theology I also admire and find extremely helpful) find them, as former cleric.s My experience of the church has been different, and the language I speak out of that experience is different. I am connected to the church institutionally in a different way than are my fellow theologians who are gay and who are ordained. The experiences that have shaped them vis-a-vis the church are different, and so they sometimes come up with different answers to the questions I have just listed than the answers for which I search as a layperson.

This I can say, however: John McNeill’s prophetic theology opens up for me and for others a way that would never have been opened to us, had he not written books such as Sex As God Intended. For what he has accomplished, and for who he is, John McNeill deserves high honor and gratitude—and not only from the gay community. From the entire church.

(Crossposted from Bilgrimage, 29 March 2009.)

2 Votes


0.000000 0.000000
Filed under: Theologians, church teaching, sexuality and gender | Tagged: changing church, gay theology, gender roles, heterosexism, homophobia, homosexuality, John McNeill, patriarchy, Progressive theologians, sexual theology

« The Bishops of Rome Edward Schillebeeckx (1914-2009): An Appreciation, Part 1 »Leave a Reply
Click here to cancel reply.
Name (required)

E-mail (will not be published) (required)

Website






Notify me of follow-up comments via email.

Notify me of new posts via email.
Open Tabernacle Team
opentabernacle
“SNAP Needs Our Help”: Guest Post Response
A Reader Responds: Mark F on “Women as Property”
colkoch
Time For The USCCB To Back Obama On Regulating Financial Sector
Haiti
Reason As The Source Of Natural Law
Spiritual Intelligence: The Master Intelligence
The USCCB Pastoral Letter On Marriage…zzzzzz
Obie Holmen
The UCC and gay ordination: thirty-eight years and counting
Roman Catholic female ordination
Prop 8 trial reveals abuses of reparative therapy
Gun sights for Jesus
ELCA Social Statements: Consensus Teaching Documents: Part I
Phillip Clark
A Belated (But Still Relevant) Response to the President’s State of the Union Address
What is the Pope’s Idea of Reform?
An attempted response to the tragic events in Haiti; God suffers with us
A Personal Reflection on the Implications of Generational Dynamics
Levi thinks “they’re people too”
Terence@queerchurch
Toward a Sound Sexual Ethic
Abuse: Germany, Netherlands, Austria – Switzerland
Vatican Paper Asks: “Where Were the Women?”
One way dialogue
Abuse & Celibacy: Austrian Cardinal Opens the Can of Worms.
William Lindsey
Mothers of Girls Excluded from Catholic School Speak Out: You Are No Longer Accepted Here
Procreation as Pro-Creation: Towards a Generativity-Centered Ethic of Sex and Marriage
From Objective Disorder to Male-Female Complementarity: The Official Catholic Response to Gay Rights Movement
Disordered Acts, Disordered Persons: Revisiting the Discussion (and Keeping It Honest)
The Foundations of Catholic Faith Meet the Lived Reality of Catholicism: Benedict’s Continued Silence about Uganda
frankcocozzelli
Bill Donohue: Defender of Glenn Beck.
When the Truth Is Shown to Be Lies
Role Models of Remonstrance
The Road to Remonstrance
Carlism and the Catholic Right
Michael Bayly
A “Fruit” Reflects Upon What It Means to Be “Fruitful”
The Underlying Dysfunction of the Denver Archdiocese’s Recent Actions
Why This Gay Man Takes Heart from the Feast of the Holy Family
Jayden Cameron
COMPANIONS ON THE JOURNEY
LIBERATED WITH JOY FROM A FAILING INSTITUTION
HOME EUCHARIST MOVEMENT
LIFE FINDS A WAY
johnjmcneill
No posts
Blogroll
Dot Commonweal
Catholic News & e-zines
America A national (U.S.) Catholic news weekly commenting on religious and political themes.
Catholica Australian Catholic e-zine, with “an excitingly different way of looking at faith and spirituality.”
Commonweal An independent journal of opinion edited and managed by lay Catholics in the U.S.
National Catholic Reporter An independent American Catholic weekly that seeks to inform and inspire a just and peaceful world, serving as a platform for discussions of church, society and global community.
New Catholic Times: sensus fidelium A Canadian bi-monthly forum for conversation about the Catholic principles of solidarity with the poor, the common good, the dignity of the human person and the presence of God in all creation.
The Progressive Catholic Voice An independent and grassroots forum for reflection, dialogue, and the exchange of ideas within the Catholic community of Minnesota (U.S.) and beyond.
U.S. Catholic A forum for lay Catholics reviewing the intersection of US cultural and political life and the Catholic faith.
Catholic Opinon & Personal blogsites
Bilgrimage This blog is me on pilgrimage, sharing my journey with companions who want to walk along–towards truth that needs to be told but doesn’t get spoken, towards whatever and whoever draws us along to the horizon of hope.
Bridget Mary's Blog A womanpriest’s personal blog: “I was ordained a priest on July 31, 2006 and am interested in discussions on spirituality. We are interested in establishing a renewed model of priestly ministry.”
Catholic Anarchy
Clerical Whispers An Irish blog seeking to give the uncomfortable truth and news from the inside of the Irish Catholic church.
Confessions of a Liturgy Queen Ross Lonergan’s blog, focusing on Catholic issues and writers, as well as the experience of being gay and Catholic.
Enlightened Catholicism A place for Catholics who don’t find their Catholic identity in the standard definitions. “He drew a circle that shut me out. Heretic, rebel, a thing to flout. But Love and I had the wit to win: We drew a circle that took him in.” Edwin Markham
Father Geoff Farrow A blog of Fr. Geoff Farrow, suspended from active ministry for speaking against proposition 8 in California, and an advocate for the rights of LGBT persons.
Gay Mystic A blog dedicated the future of a renewed, inclusive, fair and open Roman Catholic tradition, in the spirit of Pope John Paul I, and maintained by Jayden Cameron.
J. S. O'Leary A personal blog, which features “Essays on literary and theological themes”.
James Alison A website collecting the works of Rev. James Alison, a Catholic theologian whose work explores gay themes from a Catholic standpoint,
John McNeill Website Website of the pioneering (and prolific) theologian John McNeill, exploring gay themes in light of Catholic theology.
Nihil Obstat Examines public statements and letters of church officials and concerned Catholics in light of Christ’s ministry of justice and inclusion.
Perspective Thoughts of a Catholic convert
Sacredfisher Regina Colleen Heater’s sacredfisher.com is blog site is born out of the desire to reach people in both their hearts and their heads as they consider their lives in faith. The idea comes from Jesus’ call to make the apostles “fishers of men.”
The Catholic Story The website of Deacons Eric Stoltz and Vince Tomkovicz.
The Wild Reed Thoughts and reflections from a progressive, gay, Catholic perspective by blogger Michael Bayly.
There Will Be Bread Reflections about religion, life, food, faith, culture, theology, sometimes politics and more by Fran Szpylczyn.
Whispers in the Loggia Inside perspectives on matters Catholic (particularly institutional matters) by U.S. journalist Rocco Palmo.
Organizations & Resource Websites
Association of Rights of Catholics in the Church An association whose aim is “To bring about substantive structural change in the Catholic Church”, and “to institutionalize a collegial understanding of Church.”
Bishop Accountability A website documenting the abuse crisis in the Catholic Church.
Call to Action Catholics working together for justice and action.
Catholic Association for Lesbian and Gay Ministries The website of the National (U.S.) Association of Catholic Diocesan Lesbian and Gay Ministries (NACDLGM), fostering ministry to the LGBT community and providing educational resources.
Catholics United Promoting the message of justice and the common good found at the heart of the Catholic Social Tradition.
Center for Social Inclusion The Center for Social Inclusion identifies causes of racial inequity growing out of public policy.
DignityUSA DignityUSA envisions and works for a time when Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender Catholics are affirmed and experience dignity through the integration of their spirituality with their sexuality, and as beloved persons of God participate fully in all
Future Church FutureChurch seeks changes that will provide all Roman Catholics the opportunity to participate fully in Church life and leadership.
Institute for Progressive Christianity An ecumenical organization seeking to further awareness and understanding that the progressive tradition is rooted in core Christian gospel values, and to relate that tradition to personal faith, public policy, family, and the common good.
Mount St. Agnes Theological Center for Women A theological center for women founded to commit its resources in solidarity with women seeking fullness of life and equality in church and society.
New Ways Ministry A gay-positive ministry of advocacy and justice for lesbian and gay Catholics and reconciliation within the larger Christian and civil communities.
Roman Catholic Women Priests An international initiative within the Roman Catholic Church spiritually preparing, ordaining, and supporting women and men from all states of life, who are theologically qualified, committed to an inclusive model of Church, and called by the Holy Spirit
Saint Mychal Judge A blog devoted to encouraging greater faith, hope, and love through discussion of Father Mychal Judge, OFM, the saint of 9/11.
Soulforce Guided by principles of nonviolent resistance, Soulforce works to end the religious and political oppression of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and questioning people.
Stand up For Vatican II A campaign designed to involve the whole Church, Catholic organisations and individuals, who recognise the benefits the Second Vatican Council brought to the Church.
Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests A support network for women and men wounded by religious authority figures (priests, ministers, bishops, deacons, nuns and others).
Talk to Action “Reclaiming Citizenship, History and Faith”, Talk to Action aims to counter the religious right.
Voice of the Faithful An organization seeking to provide a prayerful voice, attentive to the Spirit, through which the Faithful can actively participate in the governance and guidance of the Catholic Church.
WATER: Women's Alliance for Theology, Ethics, and Ritual An international community of justice-seeking people who promote the use of feminist values to make religious and social change.
We Are Church An international movement committed to the renewal of the Roman Catholic Church on the basis of the Second Vatican Council (1962-1965) and the theological spirit developed from it.
Young Adult Catholics A blog dedicated to the progressive, faithful, Catholic voices of 20- and 30-year-olds and sponsored by Call to Action.
Other Christian Websites &Blogs
Association of Welcoming and Affirming Baptists A website of churches, organizations, and individuals on record as welcoming and affirming all persons without regard to sexual orientation or gender identity, who have joined to advocate for full inclusion of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender person
Cross Left The online enagement organization of the Institute for Progressive Christianity and its strategy clearing-house and central hub for grassroots activism among progressive Christians.
Ekklesia An ecumenical religion and society think-tank at the cutting edge of culture, spirituality and politics.
Faith in America The mission of Faith In America is to educate the public about the harm caused to gay Americans when religion-based bigotry and prejudice is used to justify condemnation, discrimination and violence toward this minority population group.
Göran Koch-Swahne Swedish personal blog
Goodsoil Goodsoil is a collaboration of organizations working for the full inclusion of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people and their families in the full ministerial and sacramental life of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA).
Lutheran News A website providing Lutheran news of interest.
Lutheran News Aggregates news and blog comments on Lutheran and other churches.
Reconciling Ministries Network A movement of United Methodist individuals, congregations, campus ministries, and other groups working for the full participation of all people in the United Methodist Church.
Religion Dispatches A daily online magazine dedicated to the analysis and understanding of religious forces in the world today, highlighting a diversity of progressive voices and aimed at broadening and advancing the public conversation.
Street Prophets A blog about faith and politics sponsored by Daily Kos.
The Liberal Spirit A blog of progressive religious themes.
Statcounter
Blog at WordPress.com. Theme: Digg 3 Column by WP Designer